Carla had grown up with the Bible and showed an early interest in studying it academically. Even in her early schooling, she showed great academic aptitude, and when it came time for college she applied to what she decided was the best Christian school for her and chose to major in Bible. She graduated at the top of her class and got an early start in Hebrew and Greek. Feeling called to an academic vocation of some sort, she applied to a master’s program and expanded her academic skills, becoming expert in using all the tools necessary for in-depth textual analysis. As she neared the end of her program, even though she was accepted into several of the top doctoral programs, she felt she wanted to use her acquired skills to serve the church directly rather than going on to a PhD and entering academia. She began teaching adult Bible studies in her church and soon had a loyal following of men and women who benefited from her skills and gifts.
When her husband took a new job in another city, they found a church that was looking for a director of women’s ministries. She started a Bible study for women, since the church didn’t allow women to teach men. As the women began to share at home what they had been learning, some husbands asked whether they could attend because it was such an academically robust study. Carla had no problems with that; she had had a very fruitful ministry at her previous church. The elders, however, did not share her opinion. “The Bible says that a woman cannot teach a man!” In spite of the support from both male and female attendees, and despite her well-established credentials and gifts, the elders held firm in their stand, appealing to the authority of 1 Timothy 2:12. Some of the women in the church who were well-schooled in this view agreed with the elders. Those in support quoted spiritual-gifting verses and Galatians 3:28. The church was in an uproar as biblical authority came under debate.
Why Understanding Biblical Authority Matters
This illustration sets the scene well for what this book wants to address: Christians desperately want to appeal to biblical authority to substantiate their positions on theological and social issues of all sorts. Similarly fraught scenarios related to dozens of different controversial issues recur regularly across the Christian landscape, from denominations and churches to homes and family gatherings, heavily populating YouTube channels, podcasts, and the blogosphere. Appeals to biblical authority, however, will be fatally flawed if we fail to grasp the nature and focus of biblical authority. If we seek to enlist biblical authority to settle our disputes but have not properly understood the nature of biblical authority, we are only using the Bible bullishly to impose our views on others. As Andy Stanley observes with disappointment, “We leverage our sacred text to validate our political talking points” (Andy Stanley, Not in It to Win It: Why Choosing Sides Sidelines the Church, Zondervan, 2022). The church must be better than this. The Bible deserves more respect than we are giving it.
READING THE BIBLE WELL AND USING IT FAITHFULLY
Why Scripture Is Foundational to Christian Faith
The Bible is sacred—so say the Christian creeds that address it, and many Christians believe that passionately, myself included. I was raised on the Bible—it was mother’s milk—and my profession, my vocation, and my ministry for fifty years has been centered on the Bible, specifically the Old Testament.
As important as it is as sacred Scripture, for many of us the Bible is also intimately personal, not because it is our profession but because we find it to be our life foundation. Those who consider themselves people of the Book immerse themselves in it; they cherish it; they build their lives on it.
Theological descriptions such as revelation, inspiration, and authority, true as they may be, do not begin to capture the value of this treasure. Our convictions, beliefs, decisions, our very lives are founded on what we firmly embrace as God’s Word. I admire such convictions, and I aspire to be characterized by that personal passion. This is who we are as the church. Asa professor, these are my people. This is the audience to whom I am writing.
The Challenges of Reading and Interpreting Scripture
Despite all these deep feelings about the Bible, the path to reading it well is not a smooth one. It often evokes confusion and controversy. Difficult passages haunt us and occasionally ensnare us in conflicted feelings about some of what God does and with apparent contradictions between texts. Devotional guides often steer us clear of the toughest material, but anyone who has tried to read through the Bible cover to cover knows well that unsettled feeling of encountering the otherness of the Bible, when it no longer feels cozy and comfortable. We can try to suppress the uneasiness and seek solace in the sure and steady favorites as we cling to faith. But those problem passages do not just go away.
Why Christians Disagree About Biblical Interpretation
Beyond the confusion, however, a tragedy plagues our passion for the Bible: We argue. We argue about doctrine at every turn, whether major or minor points. Heaven and hell, the nature of the atonement, the shape of the end times, baptism and communion, predestination, the humanity of Jesus, the historicity of Adam and Eve, women’s roles in the church, original sin, spiritual warfare—the list is practically endless. Beyond topics such as these, which are esoteric or academic issues for many, we also argue about social issues that matter deeply to us. Abortion, evolution, immigration, Christian nationalism, LGBTQ+ issues, divorce and remarriage, bioethics, creation care—again, an endless array. In our contentious disputes, everyone wants to insist that the Bible is on their side, or, perhaps more aspirationally, that they are on the Bible’s side. This is also what the church often does. We seek to enlist the Bible in support of our agendas and positions, and in the process we run the risk of commandeering it or even weaponizing it. We may go so far as to villainize those who take the other side and, too often in the history of the church, we have even been willing to kill. The depths of our passion too often have revealed the depths of our depravity as we have used the Bible to give ourselves permission to conduct Crusades, to claim a Manifest Destiny, to conduct Inquisitions, to enslave, to dehumanize, and to engage in genocide. To undergird such efforts, we have manipulated the text, exploited it, and abused it.
How to Appeal to Biblical Authority Faithfully
How can we improve our understanding of what is valid appeal to biblical authority in the bitter disputes in which we are so often entangled? When there is confusion about how to interpret the Bible, we confront the disconcerting fact that people taking opposite sides in any of these debates believe they can appeal to the authority of the Bible to settle the matter. I propose that we can find a way forward by learning to read the Bible well and developing a more informed methodology for approaching issues that are vital to our faith.
Recognizing How Biblical Authority Works
The problem that I am addressing, then, is that when Christians engage in debates of substance, they often seek to support their conclusions based on an appeal to biblical authority. The power of such appeal is undermined if we do not have a clear understanding about how biblical authority works and how to identify that which has authority. I am not going to be talking about how Scripture speaks to us in its manifold and unbounded ways, or how we may find truth in it as we read. Instead, I am specifically addressing how we appeal to its authority.
Taken from The Crisis of Biblical Authority by John H. Walton ©2026 by John H. Walton. Used by permission of InterVarsity Press. www.ivpress.com
John H. Walton is professor emeritus of Old Testament at Wheaton College and Graduate School. His many books include The Lost World of Genesis One and Wisdom for Faithful Reading.


